I Tried Increasing My Protein. How Women Over 40 Can Get the Protein They Need

As women cross the 40-year mark, our bodies shift: muscle mass tends to decline, hormones change, recovery slows, and metabolism can shift. Getting enough protein becomes more than “just part of a diet” — it becomes a foundation for strength, energy, and aging well. But many women aren’t sure how much protein they need, how to distribute it, or which sources are best. This guide aims to clear that up with evidence-backed tips and real, delicious protein options.


Why Protein Matters More After 40

  • Higher-protein diets help with satiety (feeling full), which can help control appetite and support body composition (losing fat, keeping muscle). Mayo Clinic
  • After 40, your daily protein requirement often goes up (especially if doing strength training or recovering more slowly), and meals should include protein to promote muscle protein synthesis. WebMD

How Much Protein Do Women 40+ Need?

General benchmarks:

SituationRough Protein Recommendation*
Sedentary / minimal strength training~ 0.8-1.0 grams per kilogram of body weight (~ 0.36-0.45 g per lb) WebMD
Active / doing strength training regularly~ 1.1-1.5 grams/kg of body weight (0.5-0.7 g per lb) Mayo Clinic Health System

*These are general guidelines. Always adapt based on your personal health, goals, and with advice from a registered dietitian or doctor.


What Makes a Protein Source “Good”?

Look for options that are:

  1. Complete (contain all essential amino acids), or when using plant sources, combined or varied to cover the essentials. Mayo Clinic Health System
  2. Relatively lean / low in saturated fats to protect heart health. Mayo Clinic
  3. Rich in additional nutrients that women 40+ need (iron, calcium, vitamin D, omega-3s).
  4. Digestible and affordable / accessible.

Specific Examples of Good Protein Options

Below are protein sources, examples of how much protein they deliver, and why they are especially useful for women over 40.

Protein SourceApprox Protein Amount*Why It’s Especially Good
Skinless chicken breast (3 oz cooked)~ 25-30 gramsHigh in complete protein; low in saturated fat; easy to prep. Great for strength meals.
Fatty fish (salmon, mackerel, sardines; 3-4 oz)~ 20-25 grams plus omega-3sSupports heart health; anti-inflammatory benefits helpful for joints and recovery.
Eggs (whole or just whites)1 large egg ~ 6-7 g; egg white ~ 3-4 gVersatile; eggs are a complete protein. Whites reduce fat but lose some micronutrients.
Low-fat dairy (Greek yogurt, cottage cheese)Greek yogurt (1 cup) ~ 20g; cottage cheese similarAdds calcium & vitamin D for bone health; dairy proteins digest well.
Legumes & beans (lentils, chickpeas, black beans; 1 cup cooked)~ 15-18 gramsPlant-based, high in fiber and micronutrients; helps manage blood sugar and gut health.
Soy products (tofu, tempeh, edamame)Firm tofu (½ cup) ~ 10-11 g; tempeh (3.5 oz) ~ 20 gAmong the most complete plant proteins; helpful if reducing meat.
Nuts & seeds (almonds, chia, pumpkin seeds)Almonds (¼ cup) ~ 7-8 g; chia seeds (2 Tbsp) ~ 4-5 gGood for snacking; include healthy fats; helps with feelings of fullness.
Lean red meat (sirloin, lean beef, pork loin)3 oz cooked ~ 22-24 gramsRich in iron, B-vitamins; use lean cuts to limit saturated fat.

*Amounts approximate; cooking method, cut, and brand can shift values by a few grams.


Sample Daily Protein Breakdown

  • Breakfast: Greek yogurt + berries + handful of almonds → ~ 25g
  • Snack: Hard-boiled egg + piece of fruit → ~ 7g
  • Lunch: Grilled salmon salad or chicken + quinoa + greens → ~ 30-35g
  • Snack: Edamame / roasted chickpeas → ~ 10-15g
  • Dinner: Tofu stir-fry or lean beef + mixed vegetables → ~ 25-30g

Total: ~ 90-110g depending on body weight and training level — a solid range for many women over 40 who are active or strength training.


Safety & Common Pitfalls

  • Don’t rely only on protein shakes: they can help but won’t substitute for whole foods and micronutrients. Mayo Clinic warns that shakes may miss fiber, vitamins, and real food benefits. Mayo Clinic
  • Watch saturated fat: choosing lean meats or trimming visible fat, selecting low-fat dairy, and eating more plant proteins helps keep heart risk lower. Mayo Clinic
  • Kidney concerns: for healthy people, higher protein is usually safe. If you have existing kidney issues, check with your doctor. Mayo Clinic

Bonus: Visual Guide (What Your Plate Could Look Like)

a plate divided into portions, 1/2 vegetables, 1/4 protein, 1/4 whole grains and minimal healthy fats
  • Divide your plate into portions:
    • ¼ Protein — e.g. grilled salmon / chicken / tofu
    • ½ Vegetables — wide variety, colorful, some leafy greens
    • ¼ Whole grains or starchy vegetables — quinoa, sweet potato, brown rice
    • Healthy fats — olive oil, nuts, seeds, or avocado garnish
  • Add small protein snacks between meals (hard-boiled eggs, Greek yogurt, nut butters) to hit target grams without overeating at main meals.

Conclusion

If you’re a woman over 40, boosting your protein beyond the minimal levels isn’t just about appearance—it’s about preserving strength, function, and long-term health. Focus on whole-food sources, distribute protein throughout your meals, favor lean and plant-based options, and pair your diet with strength work. With these tools, the “protein confusion” gets swapped for empowered, enjoyable eating.


References:

  • Mayo Clinic: “Are high-protein diets safe for weight loss?” Mayo Clinic
  • WebMD: “How to Get the Protein You Need” WebMD
  • VerywellHealth’s lists of high protein foods. Verywell Health

Do you have any protein tips or tricks? I would love to read your comments below. Let me know what you thought of this article. Do you have any other nutrition related questions or concerns? Leave a comment and it may be the next post for I Tried That!


Discover more from I Tried That

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Follow me on Instagram for more fitness motivation and inspiration @itriedthat1




Leave a Reply

Make a one-time donation

Choose an amount

$5.00
$10.00
$20.00

Or enter a custom amount

$

Any contribution is appreciated.

Donate
Back to top arrow

Discover more from I Tried That

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading